Reviews (27)
Write a review
I personally didn't care for this product. It takes a long time to dry so it was getting all over the place. The part that did get dried seemed to stay on well though.
Posted by Angie on 15th Nov 2019
This is the 3rd product I’ve purchased from the All Natural Face and I’m not disappointed with this or the other items. I normally don’t like this type of brush but this is sturdy and I can draw a really good line, color is great and this stays all day! Thank you!
Posted by Debbie Saleh on 24th Sep 2018
I am so glad that they have it in brown. My eyes are no longer irritated, which was my main concern when using other eyeliners. Will definitely buy again.
Posted by Lily on 14th Sep 2018
Very happy with this eyeliner, it goes on smoothly, easy to control, stays on but washes off easily. The price is also amazing, compared to other natural products, will definitely keep ordering
Posted by Erica on 3rd Mar 2017
I've been looking for a good quality, natural liquid eyeliner to replace my conventional one and this is great! The brush is very small so it's easy to use and the color is a dark, rich brown.
Posted by Lauren on 9th Feb 2017
This has been a staple in my makeup regiment. One of the very few makeup products I repurchase. I've tried many of their colors but this one is perfect. Very dark brown. I don't like using black because I find it harsh looking. It goes on easily and stays throughout the day. Seriously my favorite.
Posted by marilynagram on 23rd Mar 2016
I am in love with all the products. The eyeliner goes on very well, and love that it's a safe product to put around my eyes.
Posted by Jacie on 3rd Dec 2015
I love small applicator,I could create a nice thin lines. This eyeliner doesn't irritate my eyes and stays on all day. I think I'll try another colours.
Posted by Zuzana on 21st Nov 2015
I'd been looking for a replacement for my Almay Intense i-Color liquid liner in Brown Topaz and I was pleased that this one is so similar! (Minus the shimmer.) The color is beautiful: it's a great alternative to black for someone fair. This is perfect for my everyday cat-eye look and the brush allows for a really sharp line. It stays on all day yet isn't a pain to wash off.
Posted by undefined on 23rd Oct 2015
It doesn't claim to be waterproof and is not, but it goes on very smoothly and has a great (very fine) applicator brush.
Posted by undefined on 30th Jun 2015
The eyeliner is a good dark brown which is exactly what I wanted and the brush is skinny so you can apply a really thin line or build it up. However, I noticed the eyeliner did fade as the day went on and I had to reapply before my evening out. It doesn't smudge or flake though which is great. Would I buy it again? Yes, as long as you don't mind touching up, it's a great value for day to day use because it's not that expensive.
Posted by undefined on 24th May 2015
This is my essential liquid eyeliner. It has been a repeat buy. It lasted me a long time and I finally had to buy another. I love the matte dark brown color.
Posted by Marilyn on 13th Apr 2015
My eyes and lids are sensitive and easily irritated so I've not worn liquid eyeliner in years. I thought I'd try one more time when I read the wonderful ingredients list and I'm delighted with this product! No more eye irritation and no smudging. Fantastic!
Posted by Pamela Haack on 25th Mar 2015
This was my first purchase from TANF and I am HOOKED. This is an excellent dupe for the Almay Intense I-Color liquid liner in Brown Topaz (minus the slightly metallic shine). The applicator will take a little getting used to, as it's a very thin brush at the end of a wand and I'm used to a felt tip, but I love how precise I can make my winged liner. This applicator will also keep me from getting too heavy-handed with my liner! I do have oily lids and always use a primer, so I can only vouch for it in conjunction with a primer, but it stayed dark and stayed put all day, no smudging!
Posted by undefined on 19th Mar 2015
I like the way it goes on smoothly and stays once it's dry.
Posted by Madeleine on 2nd Dec 2014
I used to hate wearing liquid liner but I love this stuff! Goes on so smooth! Precise lines. I will recommend to others and definitely purchase again.
Posted by Jessica on 30th Nov 2014
I purchased both the black and hot fudge gel eyeliners recently, having used both over the years. As I said in my review of the black, the tip which has slimmed, makes for ease of applying and a very smooth line. Your gel eyeliners are wonderful!
Posted by Plant Based Nana on 11th Nov 2014
I've been using the Stilla liquid eyeliner for my everyday make-up, but this is a fantastic vegan alternative! I love using it and it's so easy going on. My only complaint is that it fades throughout the day, but even that isn't a big deal because it fades beautifully. And it washes off so easily at the end of the day! No painful scrubbing.
Posted by undefined on 19th Oct 2014
I was skeptical about "smudge proof" but it is really smudge proof! This color is the best for me because this brownie brown is not too strong. The brush is very thin and easy to draw a line. Perfect natural eyeliner!!!
Posted by Hitomi on 30th Apr 2014
Easy to apply. Great color. Does not smear or smudge.
Posted by Lisa Riedel on 26th Mar 2014
I love the look of liquid eyeliner and this stuff is a great natural alternative.
The formula is smooth and rich, providing saturated matte color. I find that this eyeliner requires a base (for my oily eyelids) for longevity, however it is beautiful and so affordable.
Posted by undefined on 21st Mar 2014
I have used eyeliners for years now, & this is my all time favourite so far.
it stays all day, (even in hot Australian summer temps.) Is easy to apply. Doesn't smudge. It's easy to remove, even with just water. & I love the brown colour, it gives me a much more natural look as opposed to the black I am used to using.
I'm very happy with this product & I will repurchase when I've used it all.
Posted by Charlotte on 2nd Mar 2014
I bought this not really having that high of expectations, all other natural eyeliners I've tried have smudged so bad. This one is different, it is easy to apply, doesn't smudge. Hot Fudge Brownie is a very nice matte dark brown. I just purchased 3 more colors.
Posted by undefined on 17th Feb 2014
I've recently decided to become vegan in my cosmetics and eyeliner is my staple piece. Therefore, I'm very happy to say that this eyeliner is just what i needed. It allows me to achieve a lovely clean line and it dries pretty easily. Extremely dark mind. Only problem is that a few hairs on the brush have bent in off-ward directions, although that's to be expected with a natural brush rather than plastic.
Posted by undefined on 4th Feb 2014
I was on the hunt for an all natural eyeliner and was afraid that because this wasn't "waterproof", that it would smudge on me. But it stays on all day until I wash it off at the end of the day. I just have to be careful to not blink too much right after I apply it so it doesn't transfer to under my eyes, but once it's dried, it's pretty set!
Posted by undefined on 28th Dec 2013
I am very pleased with this eye liner. It gives a very precise line being that the applicator is pretty thin,you can achieve a really clean line. It does not smudge either. The hot fudge color is perfect, almost black but not quite. I recommended it.
Posted by undefined on 24th Dec 2013
This is a great eyeliner. It's really smooth and light (I can't even feel it on). When you put it on, it stays on (until you wash it off, and that's easily done as well), no flaking off and leaving dark circles under your eyes.
Posted by Havery on 28th Oct 2013
